Groin Hernias


Inguinal Hernias

  1. Open Approach Anatomy
    1. Inguinal Canal
      • has 4 borders: external oblique fascia (superficial), transversalis fascia (deep), abdominal aponeurotic arch (superior), and inguinal ligament (inferior)
      • extends between the internal (deep inguinal) ring and the external (superficial inguinal) ring openings
      • contains either the spermatic cord or the round ligament of the uterus

      Anatomy of the Inguinal Canal
      1. External Oblique Fascia
        • reflects posteriorly in a curvilinear fashion to form the inguinal ligament
        • inguinal ligament extends from the anterior superior iliac spine to the pubic tubercle
        • lacunar ligament represents the most medial extent of the inguinal ligament and it attaches to the pecten pubis (Cooper’s ligament)

        External Oblique Fascia
      2. Internal Oblique Muscle
        • lowermost fibers become the cremaster muscle
        • ilioinguinal nerve runs on top of the cremaster muscle
        • medial aspect of the internal oblique aponeurosis may fuse with the aponeurosis of the transversus abdominis near the pubic tubercle to form the conjoint tendon (5-10%)

        Internal Oblique
      3. Transversus Abdominis Muscle
        • lower margin of this muscle forms a broad arch known as the transverse aponeurotic arch
        • in a primary hernia repair, this aponeurotic arch is secured to inferior structures such as the shelving edge of the inguinal ligament, iliopubic tract, or Cooper’s ligament

        Transversus Abdominis Muscle
      4. Transversalis Fascia
        • envelopes the entire abdomen and forms the femoral sheath as well as the floor of the inguinal canal
        • direct hernias develop in defects of this layer
        • incising this layer gains access to the iliopubic tract, femoral canal, and Cooper’s ligament

        Transversalis Fascia
      5. Iliopubic Tract
        • located posterior to the inguinal ligament
        • connects the inguinal ligament to the transversalis fascia
        • formed by aponeurotic fibers of the transversus abdominis muscle

        Iliopubic_tract
      6. Cooper’s Ligament (Pectineal Ligament)
        • located on the posterior aspect of the superior ramus of the pubis
        • formed by periosteum and fascial condensations

        Cooper's Ligament
    2. Inguinal Nerves
      1. Ilioinguinal Nerve
        • runs along the spermatic cord anteriorly
        • exits the inguinal canal through the external ring
        • supplies sensation to the skin of the upper and medial thigh
        • in males, it also innervates the base of the penis and upper scrotum
        • in females, it innervates the mons pubis and labia majora

      2. Iliohypogastric Nerve
        • runs between the internal oblique and transverse abdominis muscles and supplies both
        • also supplies sensation to the lateral buttock and lower abdominal wall

        Ilioinguinal and Iliohypogastric Nerves
      3. Genital Branch of the Genitofemoral Nerve
        • enters the inguinal canal lateral to the inferior epigastric vessels
        • travels in the spermatic cord or round ligament
        • in males, it supplies the ipsilateral scrotum and cremaster muscle
        • in females, it supplies the ipsilateral mons pubis and labium majus

      4. Femoral Branch of the Genitofemoral Nerve
        • travels along the femoral sheath
        • supplies the skin of the upper anterior thigh

      5. Lateral Femoral Cutaneous Nerve
        • passes inferior to the inguinal ligament
        • supplies the lateral thigh

  2. Laparoscopic Approach Anatomy
    1. Initial view

    2. Laparoscopic View of the Inguinal Region
    3. Peritoneum Reflected

    4. Inguinal Region with the Peritoneum Reflected
    5. Quadrangle of Doom and Pain
      • consists of the triangle of doom and the triangle of pain

      Quadrangle of Doom and Pain
      1. Triangle of Doom
        • anatomic space bounded by the vas deferens (round ligament) medially and the gonadal vessels laterally
        • inferior border is considered to be the peritoneal fold
        • apex of the triangle is the internal ring
        • contains the external iliac artery and vein, genital branch of the genitofemoral nerve
        • must avoid placing staples or tacks in this space

        Triangle of Doom
      2. Triangle of Pain
        • bounded inferomedially by the gonadal vessels and superolaterally by the inguinal ligament/iliopubic tract
        • contains the femoral nerve, femoral branch of the genitofemoral nerve, anterior femoral cutaneous nerve, and the lateral femoral cutaneous nerve

        Triangle of Pain
  3. Etiology and Classification of Groin Hernias
    1. Direct Hernia
      • attributed to wear-and tear stresses
      • heavy lifting, straining to urinate or defecate, and chronic coughing have been implicated as causative factors
      • smoking, systemic illnesses, and connective tissue disorders are causative factors as well
      • results from a defect in the transversalis fascia
      • located medial to the inferior epigastric vessels
      • bladder or colon is a common sliding component of a direct sac

      Laparoscopic View of a Direct Hernia
      Direct Hernia - Laparoscopy

    2. Indirect Hernia
      • results from a dilated persistent processus vaginalis
      • passes through the deep ring, lies within the spermatic cord (anterolateral side), and may descend into the scrotum
      • retroperitoneal organs such as the sigmoid colon or cecum may slide into an indirect sac
      • most common type of groin hernia

      Laparoscopic View of an Indirect Hernia
      Indirect Hernia - Laparoscopy

  4. Clinical Presentation
    • most patients present with a complaint of a bulge in the inguinal region
    • minor pain or vague discomfort may be associated with the bulge
    • having a patient Valsalva while standing will usually demonstrate the hernia
    • in difficult cases, ultrasound can be helpful

    1. Strangulation
      • causes intense pain, followed by tenderness, obstruction, and sepsis
      • occurs at the extremes of life
      • femoral hernia has the highest rate of strangulation

  5. Natural History
    1. Men
      • lifetime risk of developing an inguinal hernia is > 25%
      • nonoperative management is low risk in asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic men
      • incarceration (not strangulation) occurs at a rate of 0.18% per year
      • over time, a majority of patients become symptomatic and require surgery
      • delay in repair is not associated with increased operative complications

    2. Women
      • inguinal hernia repair in women has not been addressed in any randomized controlled trials
      • urgent repair of groin hernias is more common in women then men
      • women are thought to be at higher risk of incarceration and strangulation due to the inability of examination or imaging to reliably differentiate femoral from inguinal hernias
      • repair without watchful waiting is recommended in nonpregnant women; a laparoscopic approach may help avoid missing a femoral hernia
      • in pregnant women with an inguinal lump and pain, color-duplex ultrasound can identify round ligament varicosity, which is more common than inguinal hernia

  6. Surgical Management – Open
    • ~55% of groin hernias are repaired via the open approach
    • does not require a general anesthetic

    1. Tissue Repairs
      • main role is now in patients at high risk for mesh infections
      • recurrence rates are higher (15% - 20%) than in mesh repairs
      • may be associated with less chronic pain than mesh repairs

      1. Bassini Repair
        • consists of high ligation of the sac and suturing of the internal oblique muscle and the transverse aponeurotic arch to the shelving edge of the inguinal ligament
        • does not repair the femoral canal

        Bassini Repair
      2. Cooper’s Ligament (McVay) Repair
        • transverse aponeurotic arch is sutured to Cooper’s ligament medially up to the femoral canal
        • a transition stitch is then made to the inguinal ligament
        • closes off the femoral canal
        • relaxing incision is mandatory

        McVay Repair
      3. Shouldice Repair
        • multilayer imbricated repair of the floor of the inguinal canal
        • continuous suture approximates the iliopubic tract to the undersurface of the transverse aponeurotic arch
        • suture is then returned to its beginning by approximating the free edge of the aponeurotic arch to the shelving edge of the inguinal ligament

    2. Mesh Repairs
      • now the gold standard in the U.S.
      • recurrence rates are less than 5%
      • associated with higher incidences of chronic postprocedure pain than tissue repairs

      1. Lichtenstein (Tension-Free) Repair
        • successful hernia repair requires a total absence of tension on the suture line
        • a mesh patch is sutured inferiorly to the shelving edge of the inguinal ligament and superiorly to the internal oblique muscle and the transverse aponeurotic arch
        • medially, the mesh should overlap the pubic tubercle by 1.5 – 2.0 cm to minimize medial recurrence
        • lateral edge of the mesh is split to allow passage of the spermatic cord between the split limbs of mesh

        Lichtenstein (Tension-Free) Repair
      2. Mesh Plugs
        • after the hernia sac is dissected out, a plug is placed into the defect and secured in place
        • second piece of mesh is placed as an overlay patch over the defect and inguinal floor
        • most useful in repairing recurrent hernias

      3. Two-Layer Mesh Repairs
        • posterior leaflet is placed in the retromuscular, preperitoneal space as a sublay, and mimics the laparoscopic repair
        • anterior leaflet is placed as an onlay patch similar to a Lichtenstein repair
        • the connector functions similarly to a plug

  7. Surgical Management – Laparoscopic
    • ~ 40% of inguinal hernia repairs
    • tension-free mesh repair based on a preperitoneal approach
    • proposed advantages include quicker recovery, less pain, better visualization of anatomy, ability to fix all types of inguinal hernia defects
    • disadvantages include a high learning curve, longer OR times, increased cost, and a small chance of visceral or vascular injury
    • most clearly indicated for bilateral or recurrent hernias
    • 2 main approaches: totally extraperitoneal (TEP), and transabdominal preperitoneal (TAPP)
    • in the TEP approach, a balloon dissector is used to gain access to the preperitoneal space
    • in the TAPP approach, the preperitoneal space is accessed after initially entering the peritoneal space
    • mesh is placed retromuscularly and retroperitoneally to widely cover the myopectineal orifice
    • mesh fixation is achieved with sutures, tacks, or self-gripping mesh
    • the mesh should be completely reperitonealized

    Laparoscopic Mesh Placement

Femoral Hernias

  1. Femoral Canal Anatomy
    • boundaries: superiorly by the iliopubic tract, inferiorly by Cooper’s ligament, laterally by the femoral vein, and medially by the junction of the iliopubic tract and Cooper’s ligament (lacunar ligament)

    Femoral Canal Anatomy
  2. Clinical Presentation
    • present as a bulge below the inguinal ligament and medial to the femoral pulse
    • can be confused with a lipoma or lymph node
    • associated with a high incidence of strangulation, so all femoral hernias should be electively repaired when diagnosed

    Incarcerated Femoral Hernia - Laparoscopy
  3. Repair
    • must obliterate the defect in the femoral canal
    • this can be done with mesh, McVay repair, or laparoscopically

Complications

  1. Wound Infection
    • risk is 1% to 2%
    • clinical trials do not support the routine use of preoperative antibiotics
    • infected mesh will need to be removed

  2. Post-op Groin Pain
    • chronic groin pain occurs in up to 16% of patients following hernia repair
    • can result from neuropathic or nonneuropathic etiologies
    • nonneuropathic etiologies, such as hernia recurrence and meshoma, can cause chronic inguinal pain and should be ruled out early in the evaluation
    • an MRI of the pelvis will help identify nonneuropathic causes of pain

    1. Neuropathic Pain
      • usually secondary to mesh entrapment of a nerve, neuroma formation after nerve injury, or inappropriate laparoscopic tack application
      • symptoms include a burning or shooting pain in the nerve distribution
      • in certain situations, a regional nerve block may be both diagnostic and, at least temporarily, therapeutic
      • many neuralgias are transient and will resolve within several weeks or months
      • persistent neuralgia may be treated with serial nerve blocks or a topical lidocaine patch
      • diagnostic laparoscopy may be necessary to evaluate positioning of the mesh and tacks once nonneuropathic sources are ruled out and less invasive means of treatment have failed
      • nerves most affected in laparoscopic surgery include the lateral femoral cutaneous and genitofemoral nerves
      • similarly, in the case of an open hernia repair, resection of the nerves of the groin (i.e., resection of the ilioinguinal, iliohypogastric, and genital branch of the genitofemoral nerves) and removal of the mesh may be necessary

  3. Ischemic Orchitis
    • results from thrombosis of the pampiniform plexus in the spermatic cord or ligation of the testicular artery
    • the testicle becomes swollen and tender several days after surgery, and may persist for 6 to 12 weeks
    • outcome is usually testicular atrophy
    • treatment is with anti-inflammatory drugs and analgesics
    • orchiectomy is rarely necessary
    • prevented by avoiding unnecessary dissection in the spermatic cord – the distal portion of a large, indirect hernia sac should be left in place
    • incidence is much higher after each repair of a recurrent hernia

Recurrent Hernias

  1. Risk Factors
    1. Patient-Related
      • diabetes, wound infection, ascites, immunosuppression, connective tissue disorders, vascular disease are all associated with poor wound healing and hernia recurrence
      • smoking is associated with poor wound healing, tissue ischemia
      • smoker’s cough applies constant tension to the abdominal wall and groin

    2. Technical Factors
      • missing an indirect hernia when repairing a direct hernia
      • excessive tension on the repair
      • failure to anchor the mesh adequately at the pubic tubercle
      • improper mesh size and placement

  2. Repair
    • often best managed by a different approach, especially in cases of multiple recurrences
    • for patients who have had an anterior repair, the preperitoneal approach (open or laparoscopic) avoids the altered anatomy of the previous surgery

    1. Stoppa Procedure
      • useful for large, multiply recurrent hernias
      • large piece of mesh is place into the preperitoneal space via a lower midline incision
      • mesh is held in place by intra-abdominal pressure







References

  1. Sabiston, 20th ed., pgs 1092 - 1106
  2. Cameron, 13th ed., pgs 623 – 627, 627 - 631
  3. Schwartz, 10th ed., pgs 1495 - 1517